No More Yo-Yoing Games: An Interactive Dismantling of Diet Codes
- Susan Armstrong
- Mar 31, 2024
- 3 min read

Rewriting Your Food Rules: An Interactive Journey to Demolish Diet Rigidity
If you're someone who has struggled with disordered eating habits, chronic dieting, or a rigid, fear-based approach to nutrition, this exercise is for you. Because so much of developing a peaceful, intuitive relationship with food starts with examining the rules and distorted beliefs that kept us trapped for far too long.
On the surface, jotting down past food philosophies or diet directives may seem deceptively simple. But doing so forces you to confront some of your deepest programming around morality, guilt, and self-punishing thoughts when it comes to eating. It pulls up emotional weights you may have carried for years without realizing their subconscious impacts.
That's because our brains are incredibly harsh arbiters when we feel we've strayed from societal or personal rules. Every time we broke a diet law - whether enforced by a program, a friend, or just our own inner critic - we experience psychological lashings of anxiety, shame, and intense cognitive dissonance. "I'm being so bad" and "I have no willpower" are just two of the merciless self-flagellations we're met with.
And after internalizing these narratives for years through constant food restrictors and bingeing cycles, we cement neural pathways and cellular memories that are extremely difficult to re-wire. Even when we intellectually embrace intuitive eating or vow to never diet again, simply feeling a pang of hunger or eating a "forbidden" food can spark overwhelming senses of deprivation and panic.
That's where this written exercise comes in. By physically recording some of the hard-line rules you used to live by, you are forced to become aware of their lingering subconscious effects and just how rigid, extreme, and often antithetical to your wellbeing they were. Externalizing them onto the page takes away their power to scurry around in the shadows of your mind, wreaking havoc on your psyche and self-worth.
Ready to begin unpacking?
Here's what to do:
First, make two columns on a piece of paper or notebook. At the top of one, write "Past Rigid Food Rules or Diet Beliefs." For the other column, simply put "Still Resonant?"
Now cast your mind back across all previous eating eras and mindsets. And without judging or censoring, begin listing out any staunch rules or rigid beliefs you upheld about food, body size, nutrition, etc. These may have originated from outdated programs like cabbage soup or Atkins, family messaging about finishing your plate, or just your own self-critical inner monologue.
Examples could include:
• Carbs are bad and must be avoided
• Being full is a sign of failure
• Dessert is only for special occasions or being "good"
• Skipping meals is being virtuous
• Looking a certain way determines your worth and lovability
As you let these past rules flow, notice any feelings of discomfort, panic, guilt, or anxiety that arise as you reconnect with them on paper. Those are signs you still harbor deep associations between your sense of self and these beliefs. So in the second column, circle any rules or philosophies that still evoke those psychological danger signals.
Once you've excavated and cataloged as many as possible, take a step back. Read them aloud, let their toxicity and oppressive weight sink in. Then decide, rationally, if these are really rules you want dictating your mindset and behaviors around food moving forward.
For so many who have recovered from chronic dieting, simply pausing to reflect on past deprivation programming can feel jarringly eye-opening. It's a powerful exposure exercise for divorcing yourself from harmful indoctrination so you can replace it with food freedom and gentle nutrition.
Because the truth is, so many rigid rules we adopted were rooted in morality rather than health. They sprang from fear, control, and a zero-sum mentality of being "good" or "bad" based on a day's eating. Until we have the courage to shine light on the arbitrary, harmful rules we clung to and intentionally release them, they'll always linger in our subconscious like ghostly slivers of shackled conditioning.
So grab a pen, get real with yourself, and let the rewriting begin. The catharsis and perspective wait for no one.

















Comments